Our rankings are cleverly generated from the algorithmic analysis of thousands of customer reviews about products, brands, merchant's customer service levels, popularity trends, and more. The rankings reflect our opinion and should be a good starting point for shopping. As an Amazon Associate we may earn from qualifying purchases. We may receive a commission from purchases made through links on our site, which will help us continue to provide you with value.
Best Choice Fourth Estate 
Butter: THE No. 1 SUNDAY TIMES BESTSELLING SENSATION Audible 
BUTTER Best Value BEGA 
Bega Smooth Peanut Butter 2 kg Never oily, never dry peanut butterBEGA 
Bega Smooth Peanut Butter, Never Oily Never Dry, Jar 470g Source of protein, vitamin B3 & magnesiumPIETRO LAB 
PIETRO Lab Macadamia Butter 100% | Australian Macadamias | No Additives or Fillers | 250g 100% PURE MACADAMIA NUTS with NO added ingredientsBEGA 
Bega Crunchy Peanut Butter, Never Oily Never Dry, Bulk Pail 2kg Source of protein, vitamin B3 & magnesiumBEGA 
Bega Crunchy Peanut Butter, Never Oily Never Dry, Jar 470g Source of protein, vitamin B3 & magnesiumHonest to Goodness Honest to Goodness Organic Maple Butter, 250g Maple butter is deliciously sweet and can be used as a butter substitute or dairy and nut-free spreadBega Bega Smooth Peanut Butter, Never Oily Never Dry, Jar 375g Source of protein, vitamin B3 & magnesium18% Off BEGA Bega Simply Nuts, Smooth Natural Peanut Butter, With A Pinch Of Salt, 100% Australian Peanuts, Jar 325g Smooth Peanut ButterAudible Butter Witch: Torrent Witches, Book 1 18% Off BEGA Bega Simply Nuts, Crunchy Natural Peanut Butter, With A Pinch Of Salt, 100% Australian Peanuts, Jar 325g Country Of Origin : Australia42% Off Generic Pure Organic Shea Butter Raw 4.2 OZ, Raw Shea Butter, Unrefined Shea Butter for Hair and Body, Enriched with vitamins A, 【Original Ingredient Shea Butter】our shea butter is the most original natural ingredient. It is not refined and processeAudible Butter My Biscuit: A Best Friends to Lovers Small Town Romance: Valentine Texas, Book 3 24% Off Nutty Bruce Nutty Bruce Smooth Almond Butter Spread - 250g Pure nut butter spread with no added anything!Audible Butter SKIPPY Skippy Creamy Peanut Butter 1.8kg Bulk Value Pack Made in USA Roasted peanuts (91%), sugar, hydrogenated vegetable oil, salt.Mayver's Mayver's Crunchy Peanut Butter 750 g 5 HEALTH STAR RATEDBEGA Bega Super Crunchy Peanut Butter, Never Oily Never Dry, Jar 470g Gluten Free22% Off BEGA Bega Crunchy Peanut Butter, Never Oily Never Dry, Jar 375g Source of protein, vitamin B3 & magnesiumMayver's Mayver's Smooth Peanut Butter 750 g 5 HEALTH STAR RATEDBEGA Bega Crunchy Peanut Butter, No Added Sugar or Salt, Never Oily Never Dry, Jar 325g No added salt or sugarCraveable Cookbooks Secret Recipes Using Peanut Butter: Sweet and savory recipes including cookies, sauces, noodles, brownies, breakfast bit 28% Off Generic Shea Butter Raw Organic, Raw Shea Butter, Unrefined Shea Butter for Hair and Body, Organic Shea Butter, Enriched with vi 【Original Ingredient Shea Butter】our shea butter is the most original natural ingredient. It is not refined and processePIETRO LAB PIETRO Lab Hazelnut Butter 100% | Natural Nut Butter | No Additives or Fillers | 250g 100% PURE HAZELNUT BUTTER with no additivesAustralian Wholesale Oils Australian Wholesale Oils Refined Certified Organic Shea Butter 1 kg Has been used in skin and hair care for generationsAudible The Butterfly Garden: The Collector, Book 1 Generic Slow Rebound Cute Butter Squeeze Stress Balls, Soft Big Squeeze Butter Squishy Stick for Stress Relief, ButterStick Squi 【Adorably Realistic Butter Design】Experience charm with a stick-shaped butter squishy, perfect for adding a dash of funUQGVML Butter Squishy Stress Gadget for Adults, Slow Rebound Sensory Fidget, 13.5cm/5.3in Soft Yellow Block for Office Home, St 【Slow Rebound Stress Relief】This cute butter shape ornament is made of ultra-soft slow-rising material, it delivers gentBarney Butter Barney Butter Powdered Almond Butter, Unsweetened, 8 Ounce ONE INGREDIENT PROTEIN BOOST: Contains an 8 ounce jar of Barney Unsweetened Powdered Almond Butter perfect for almond buKicttule Giant Butter Squishy 14cm, Extra Large Slow Rising Stress Reliever, Super Soft Sensory Fidget Pad for Anxiety & Autism, Giant 14cm Size – Much bigger than standard squishies, looks like real butter.Honest to Goodness Honest to Goodness Organic Peanut Butter Smooth, 2kg Honest to Goodness Organic Smooth Peanut Butter is made from 100% ground, roasted and blanched peanuts - purely nuts!KIRKLAND Kirkland Signature Creamy Almond Butter 765g Made from high quality finest ingredients which is refreshingPIETRO LAB PIETRO Lab Pistachio Butter 100% | High Protein Nut Butter | Australian Pistachios | 250g PREMIUM 100% PURE PISTACHIO BUTTER with no additivesBEGA Bega Crunchy Light Peanut Butter, 25% Less Fat, Never Oily Never Dry, Jar 470g Source of protein, vitamin B3 & magnesium40% Off Generic Giant Butter Squishy, Jumbo Squishy Butter Stick, 4oz/14oz Slow Rebound Squeeze Butter, Stress Relief Slow Rising Fun (2 【BIG BUTTERY FUN】Over 10 inches long, this jumbo squishy butter stick is perfect for one- or two-handed squeezing, provi49% Off Fourth Estate Hooked: The new instant Sunday Times bestseller from the award-winning author of BUTTER Audible The Butterfly Women Irish Black Butter Irish Black Butter - 225 g A brand new product made in Ireland"18% Off MFAUCAZB Butter Dish with Lid 5.83" Large Butter Dish for Countertop Bohemian Ceramic Cheese Keeper Container with Knife and Bamb 【 Ceramic Craftsmanship 】The lidded countertop butter dish is made of ceramic , making it sturdy and resistant to crackiCoconut Magic Coconut Magic Organic Coconut Butter 350 g Creamy coconut butter from whole raw coconut fleshWREANU Giant Butter Squishy, Jumbo Squishy Butter Stick, 2pcs-4oz/14×4×4cm Slow Rebound Squeeze Butter, Stress Relief Slow Risi 【BIG BUTTERY FUN】This item include 2pcs-4oz/14×4×4cm, this jumbo squishy butter stick is perfect for one- or two-handedNoya Noya - Organic Almond Nut Butter 200g 100 Percent natural nut butter10% Off COCO EARTH Coco Earth Grass Fed Ghee Butter 500ml | Pure Ghee | Clarified Butter 500ml Made from 100% pure cow milk using traditional slow-churned methodsMayver's Mayver's Smooth Peanut Butter 750 g (Pack of 2) The information below is per-pack onlyPIETRO LAB PIETRO Lab Black Sesame Butter 100% | Natural, High Protein Seed Butter | No Additives or Fillers | 250g 100% PURE BLACK SESAME with intense flavorHonest to Goodness Honest to Goodness Almond Butter, 1kg Almond Butter, also known as Almond Spread is a healthy and delicious natural spread made from 100% pure, Oven Roasted ANiulife Niulife Organic Coconut Butter 500 g Melt and pour over ice-creamMandolé Orchard Mandolé Orchard - Premium Australian Almond Butter - Smooth Unsalted, 250g (Pack of 2) The information below is per-pack only43% Off Palmer's PALMER'S Tummy Butter for Stretch Marks, 125g Helps reduce the appearance of stretch marksALINUOYQ Butter Squish y, Slow Rebound Cute Butter Stick Squish y Toy, Realistic Butter Stick Soft Squeeze Toy, Stres s Relief Fi Butter squish y: Realistic and adorable butter stick squish y toy with a fun, eye‑catching look. Perfect for squish y toCeres Organics Ceres Organic Pumpkin Seed Butter 220 g Slather over your favourite snack or blend into smoothies or saucesArtisana Artisana Organics Raw Pecan Butter 8 oz 227 g Generic Cravers 100% Hazelnut Butter 250g Gluten-free, Vegan, High in dietary fiber, Plant-based protein, Keto-FriendlyKIRKLAND Kirkland Signature - Creamy Almond Butter, 27 Ounce - 2 Jars Creamy Almond ButterShunTianFeng 2Pcs Butter Squishy, Slow Rebound Cute Butter Squeeze Stress Balls,Soft Big Squeeze Butter Squishy Stick for Stress Reli Adorably Realistic Butter Design Experience the charm of a stick-shaped butter squishy that adds a fun touch to your dayDastony Dastony, Organic Sprouted Pumpkin Seed Butter, 16 oz (454 g) A single premium organic ingredient made from carefully selected sprouted pumpkin seeds, our butter guarantees the highePQLQ Butter Squishy Stress Gadget for Adults, Slow Rebound Sensory Fidget, Soft Yellow Block for Office Home, Stress Relief G 【Slow Rebound Stress Relief】This cute butter shape ornament is made of ultra-soft slow-rising material, it delivers gentEVERY BIT ORGANIC RAW Every Bit Organic Live Wholefoods Activated Almond Butter 250g, Organic Almonds Soaked with Kombucha for a Smooth and Cr Activated Organic Almond Butter: Crafted from premium organic almonds that are soaked and gently dehydrated to enhance fThe Butter Pecan Cupcake : culinary murder mystery (Amateur baker detective Book 9) Australian Wholesale Oils Australian Wholesale Oils Aloe Vera Butter 500 g Promotes healing and skin hydrationCeres Organics Ceres Organic Cashew Butter 220 g Simply two ingredients blended togetherHonest to Goodness Honest to Goodness Organic Coconut Butter, 1kg Organic Coconut Butter is a nutritious, melt-in-our-mouth spread made from 100% certified organic coconut flesh.Hustle Butter Deluxe Hustle Butter Deluxe – Tattoo Butter for Before, During, & After the Tattoo Process – Lubricates & Moisturizes – 100% Ve TATTOO AFTERCARE ESSENTIAL: Hustle Butter is the original tattoo aftercare balm for new and older tattoos. With over 10Nutiva Nutiva Organic Coconut Manna Puréed Coconut Butter, 15 Oz, USDA Organic, Non-GMO, Vegan, Gluten-Free & Keto, Creamy Spre Warm it up to spread the goodnessSKIPPY SKIPPY Creamy Peanut Butter, 64 Ounce Creamy peanut butter made with real roasted peanutsByron Bay Peanut Butter Co Byron Bay Peanut Butter Smooth Unsalted G/F 375g A light easy to spread snack perfect for breakfast, lunch or an after dinner treatIndicow Indicow Farms A2 Cow Ghee/Clarified Butter | Hand Churned, Bilona | Organic Grass fed Ghee | Keto and Paleo friendly (A2 MADE FROM CURD: Our A2 Desi Cow Ghee is 100% pure, preservative-free, chemical-free, and cruelty-free. Fresh A2 milk obtHonest to Goodness Honest to Goodness Organic Crunchy Peanut Butter, 2kg Honest to Goodness Certified Organic Crunchy Peanut Butter is a delicious, nutty spread made from 100% roasted and blancHarperCollins Children's Books Butter Noya Noya - ABC Chia Nut Butter 100 Percent natural nut butterGeneric Pure Organic Shea Butter Raw 4.2 OZ (2 pack), Raw Shea Butter, Unrefined Shea Butter for Hair and Body, Enriched with vi 【Original Ingredient Shea Butter】our shea butter is the most original natural ingredient. It is not refined and processeRidiculously Delicious Ridiculously Delicious Crazy Crunch Peanut Butter 375 g Roasted Australian peanut butter29% Off Quest Quest Nutrition Peanut Butter Cups, High Protein, Low Carb, Keto Friendly, 12 Count You deserve a sweet treat: Quest Peanut Butter Cups are indulgent treats that satisfy your sweet tooth with less than 1gBIRCH & MEADOW Birch & Meadow Butter Powder, 1.2 lbs, Popcorn Topping, Rich & Creamy, Butter Substitute Birch & Meadow Butter Powder20% Off Chronicle Books The Butter Book Power Super Foods Power Superfoods Organic Cacao Gold Butter Chunks 250 g Creamy cacao butter chunks with a rich aromaArtisana Artisana Organics Raw Walnut Butter with Cashews, 8 oz ONLY TWO INGREDIENTS: The only ingredients you will find in our Walnut Butter is 100% organic, pure walnuts and cashews—Mayver's Mayvers Smunch Almond Butter 240 g Made from just pure AlmondsHonest to Goodness Honest to Goodness Almond Butter, 240g Almond Butter, also known as Almond Spread is a healthy and delicious natural spread made from 100% pure, Oven Roasted AFix-it Pure Organic Shea Butter, Natural Raw Unrefined - for Hair, Skin, Body, Face & Lips - Enriched with Vitamins for Intense 🍁1. 100% Pure & Unrefined: Made from natural shea nuts and minimally processed to maintain its original texture and ricSKIPPY Skippy Super Chunk Extra Crunchy Peanut Butter, 64 Ounce One 64 oz. jar of SKIPPY SUPER CHUNK Peanut Butter Spread. Four simple ingredients with a sweet and savory peanut flavor30% Off Natio Natio Australia Wellness Body Butter 240g - Cocoa Butter, Shea Butter, Pomegranate & Olive Leaf - Intensively Hydrating, Rich, nourishing body moisturiserLionsgate Butter Shrink-wrapped22% Off SpaScriptions Spascriptions Brightening Sweet Mango Body Butter 295 ml MANGO is rich in antioxidants, boosts hydration and helps skin's tone appear even.43% Off Murdoch Books First, Cream the Butter and Sugar: The essential baking companion Nosy Crow Kitty Capers: A Peanut, Butter & Crackers Story Audible Butter Cookies and Demon Claws (Dramatized Adaptation): A Demon Cycle Novella Crazy Aaron's Crazy Aaron's® Better Butter Buttercream Thinking Putty® Includes 2.1oz (60 g) of Genuine Crazy Aaron’s Better Butter Buttercream Thinking Putty Better Butter Thinking Putty isRidiculously Delicious Ridiculously Delicious Chunky Crunch Peanut Butter 375 g Made from high quality ingredientsReaNea Butter Dish with Lid for Countertop and Refrigerator Door Shelf, ReaNea Plastic Butter Holder Tray Container with Butter BUTTER DISH WITH LID: This butter dish comes with a lid that protects the butter from dust, bugs, and other things thatFix-it 100% Pure Organic Raw Shea Butter – Unrefined Natural Moisturiser for Body, Face & Hair – Intensive Hydration for Dry Cr ►100% PURE & NATURAL SKIN CARE: Experience the power of nature with our unrefined and raw shea butter. This pure moisturMigugaga Butter Crock with Spreader, French Butter Keeper with Water Line for Counter, The Original Porcelain Butter Dish. Cerami 【 Get Soft, Spreadable Butter On Demand for up to 10 Days 】Nothing tastes quite like your favorite soft creamy butter, sBestJJ Slow Rising Squishy Butter Stick, 1pcs 14oz Soft Butter Stick Squishies Toy, Sensory Fidget Toy for Stress Relief & Calm 【Safe & Durable Material】Made from non-toxic PU foam, this slow rising squishy butter stick is durable, long-lasting, anMaxwell & Williams Maxwell & Williams Epicurious Butter Dish Black Porcelain Gift Boxed Durable Porcelain Construction: Made from high-quality porcelain material that ensures long-lasting durability and elega